Two Catholic members of Congress reflect on assault on U.S. Capitol and their hopes for the future
Jan 11, 2021
US & World
Seeing the U.S. Capitol building being stormed by a rioting mob on Jan. 6, 2021 brought a visceral reaction from Congressman Jeff Fortenberry, a Republican from Nebraska. Rep. Fortenberry, who is Catholic and often attends daily Mass at St. Peter’s Church on Capitol Hill, called the attack on the Capitol a “desecration.”
The rioters broke through windows and doors, overwhelmed Capitol Police lines and rampaged through the building, causing members of Congress and staff to flee to secure areas, as the mob proceeded to ransack congressional offices and wander into the abandoned Senate chamber.
“When I saw (TV images of) a fool in the chair of the presiding officer of the Senate, my visceral reaction was (this is) desecration,” Rep. Fortenberry said in a Jan. 8 interview with the Catholic Standard newspaper and website of the Archdiocese of Washington.
The congressman, who has a master’s degree in public policy from Georgetown University and a master’s degree in theology from the Franciscan University of Steubenville, Ohio, said that “desecration” of the U.S. Capitol reminded him of how, during the Reign of Terror in the French Revolution, a prostitute was installed on the altar of the Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris.
“The degradation of culture leads to these moments where violence can be pursued in the name of justice. That’s how twisted this is,” he said.
Rioters confront U.S. Capitol Police after storming the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. (CNS photo/Ahmed Gaber, Reuters)
When the crowd stormed the Capitol, Rep. Fortenberry was quarantined in his office because of COVID-19 exposure, allowed to return for votes under safety precautions. He said from the front side of the Longworth Building, he could see the chaos erupting around the outside of the Capitol, and from the back side of his building, life was unfolding as normal, and a man could be seen walking his dog.
“It was jarring and surreal at the same time,” he said of the mob’s siege of the Capitol. “I could not imagine this could happen in the United States of America… To think somehow in the pursuit of justice and democracy, people would take over the Capitol. It’s not only jarring, but outrageous.”
Rep. Fortenberry said that assault was “a threat not just to this space, but to the idea of America.”
As that unfolded, the member of Congress said “your sense of duty kicks in,” and he was contacting his staff members and fellow members of Congress to make sure they were safe, just as he was receiving numerous texts wondering if he was okay.
Congressman Jeff Fortenberry, a Republican from Nebraska, represents that state’s First Congressional District in the United States House of Representatives. (Photo from his website)
Congressman Matt Rosendale, a Republican from Montana who also attends daily Mass at St. Peter’s Church on Capitol Hill, was in the House chambers along with other members that afternoon, listening to debate about objections raised regarding the Electoral College vote from Arizona.
About an hour into the debate, he said they heard an announcement over the loudspeaker that there had been a breach in the Capitol’s security. The Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi, was escorted out of the chamber. Rep. Rosendale said that members were advised to get the gas masks under their seats and then to leave the room, after tear gas had been used to disperse rioters in the Capitol Rotunda.
“I tried to do my best to keep folks calm,” he said in an interview with the Catholic Standard. “There was an orderly evacuation. Everybody had a gas mask in hand. They got us out of the chamber and started taking us to a secure place.”
During the melee, Rep. Rosendale said they could hear rioters beating on the doors. Dozens of people were arrested for the rioting in the Capitol, and in the aftermath, five people died, including a Capitol Hill Police officer and four people who had been part of the protest that turned into a riot. One woman had been shot by a Capitol Hill Police officer, and three others died after suffering medical emergencies. Tens of thousands of people had gathered in Washington that day to protest following President Trump's claims that the election had been stolen from him due to alleged voting fraud in several swing states. More than 60 different courts across the country, including the Supreme Court, rejected lawsuits making those claims.
Reflecting on the attack on the Capitol, Rep. Rosendale said, “It’s troubling to me, as I sit there and try to perform my duties in this great free society… there were people outside violating everyone’s First Amendment right to free speech. They had crossed over the line by committing criminal acts… It’s contrary to everything we were trying to do up here.”
Like Rep. Fortenberry, he wanted to make sure his staff members were safe. Meanwhile, Rep. Rosendale’s wife Jean was among people who sought sanctuary that afternoon in St. Peter’s Church, after neighbors had to evacuate their homes due to a bomb scare in a nearby building.
“We typically walk down there (to St. Peter’s) for daily Mass. We always find comfort and solace in church… It’s special for me to attend Mass each day. It’s part of my life,” he said.
On that harrowing day, the Capitol Hill church where they go to Mass became a safe haven for the congressman’s wife and for others in that community.
Hours later, the members of the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate returned to work, to listen to debate and then certify the Electoral College vote of President-elect Joe Biden. Rep. Rosendale was among members of Congress who voted in favor of objections raised to the Electoral College votes in Arizona and Pennsylvania, and Rep. Fortenberry joined members of Congress in opposing those objections. Working through the middle of the night, Congress ultimately certified the Electoral College vote on Jan. 7.
“It was critically important for the whole nation for us to go back in chambers and complete our work, and let them see nothing was going to keep us from performing our duty,” Rep. Rosendale said.
After the Capitol had been invaded by rioters, tall fencing was erected around its perimeter, with members of the National Guard patrolling the Capitol Hill area.
“Right now outside it’s very calm and very peaceful, and I have no concerns as I travel the Capitol,” Rep. Rosendale said in the interview two days after the attack.
Asked about his hopes for the future, the member of Congress said, “What I hope going forward is, this body, the U.S. Congress, both chambers, that we’re able to focus on policies and not personalities and leave all the debate inside our respective chambers.”
Congressman Matt Rosendale represents Montana in the U.S. House of Representatives. (Photo courtesy of his office)
The evening after the incident, Rep. Fortenberry walked around the Capitol building, thanking Capitol Hill Police officers.
“We see them do their duty every day,” he said, noting that he spoke with one officer that he sees all the time, but now “he was in full riot gear.”
Rep. Fortenberry also made it a point to go to Statuary Hall, and make sure Nebraska’s statue of Chief Standing Bear was unharmed. According to the website of the Architect of the Capitol that explains the figures memorialized in Statuary Hall, “Chief Standing Bear of the Ponca tribe was the central figure of an 1879 court case that established that Native Americans are ‘persons’ under the law and are entitled to the same rights as anyone else in the nation.”
Thankfully, that statue was unharmed. Reflecting on that figure in Nebraska’s history, Rep. Fortenberry said, “Chief Standing Bear was a forerunner to the Civil Rights movement. He raised his hand in the courtroom and said, ‘I am a man.’”
Asked about his hopes for the future after the assault on the U.S. Capitol, the Nebraska congressman said, “Our task now is to heal, and our flag is still flying.”